Martin 1941 D28 Authentic vs. Collings D1a

[SongwriterFan]

Originally Posted by lt20dbl

What part of "Authentic" do you not understand?

How about a torrefied top and Madagascar Rosewood back/sides?

Neither are "authentic", are they?

[lt20dbl]

Originally Posted by westman

"It is a concept that does not appeal to everyone" - to wrongly use a word.

authentic
ɔːˈθɛntɪk/
adjective
adjective: authentic

1.
of undisputed origin and not a copy; genuine.
"the letter is now accepted as an authentic document"
synonyms: genuine, original, real, actual, pukka, bona fide, true, veritable; sterling;
attested, undisputed, rightful, legitimate, lawful, legal, valid;
echt;
informalthe real McCoy, the genuine article, the real thing, your actual, kosher, honest-to-goodness;
informaldinkum;
raresimon-pure
"the first authentic Rubens in the museum's collection"

think reproductions, reissues or just plain copy's.

If it's okay with you, I'll enjoy the lovely vintage Martinesque thump of my fake Authentics while you determine the validity of my pleasure.

[golfnut]

Originally Posted by SongwriterFan

How about a torrefied top and Madagascar Rosewood back/sides?

Neither are "authentic", are they?

They are as authentic as humanly possible. Brazilian rosewood and the guys that made the originals just aren't as available.

[lt20dbl]

Originally Posted by SongwriterFan

How about a torrefied top and Madagascar Rosewood back/sides?

Neither are "authentic", are they?

As close as myself, along with many others can afford.

[Kerbie]

Guys, these are both outstanding guitars. Lots to like here. Let's see if we can keep this thread polite.

[Kerbie]

Originally Posted by Fellowlefty

I went with the Collings D1a.

Congratulations, Lefty... I think that's a great choice. The D1A is a monster... I hope you really enjoy it. Come back and tell us all about it.

[Fellowlefty]

Thanks Kerbie and Haasome

[vintageom]

I hope your Collings D1A serves you very well for many years. Very fine instrument!

[lt20dbl]

Originally Posted by vintageom

I hope your Collings D1A serves you very well for many years. Very fine instrument!

I have never owned but one Collings guitar and after 19 years, I am pretty sure there will be no need for another. It's perfect, really.

[jrb715]

Lefty,

Congratulations. I hope it perfectly suits your taste. Having played quite a few fine acoustics, though not nearly as many as some on the forum, I've found five different models of Collings a match for my needs and taste. Unless something truly bizarre happened, you'll find the Collings a beautiful guitar made with extraordinary care.

[peanutavalon]

do the 41 d-28's still get that boomy bass or is it tighter? I have a 39A d-18 with rear bracing and it is definitely not as bassy as my standard 18. Just curious if the rosewood makes it bassier. I'm looking to add a rosewood guitar but want to make sure the 41 d28 is not too similar to my 39a with rear bracing....I know its an old thread but hoping some will chime in....thanks

[SCslim]

Two very different guitars but if we are talking collings vs Martins my vote would go collings hands down every time. I’ve owned many by both and simply put the collings are much finer instruments

[wreck500]

Good thing is...there are pretty good choices for different ears and preferences. Enjoy your new guitar!

Terry

[Vinnie Boombatz]

If I was spending $6-$7k on a guitar, I'd be darn sure I played the things first and made my own decision rather than ask a bunch of strangers what they think.

[v32 finish]

I probably would, too, but some people just like to talk it out. I personally value the opinions of people on here very much who are much more experienced than I am, although at the end of the day I do realize that their tastes may not be my own..

that being said, I've also ordered a *few* guitars sight-unseen, never quite that pricey, but nearly so, and while I was nervous every time, I've never once been disappointed. Part of the thrill I guess.

Didn't realize this was an old thread until just now, but I was surprised by just how many people chimed in saying that particular Martin was literally the best guitar they'd ever heard. I've always recognized them as great instruments, but in that price range, there is a ton of really stiff competition.. probably the #1 thing that surprised me. Still waiting for a Collings OM to come through locally to play.

cheers