#46
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
|
#47
|
|||
|
|||
IMHO I take exception and what is "greatness"?
Quote:
And I really don't think anyone but Chet knew what he meant when he called Tommy "one of the greatest" but I think Chet meant what he said, and coming from Chet Atkins that had to mean something. As far as the term "greatest", greatness goes beyond playing. Greatness enfluences progress. My guitarist before including Chet and Merle, have enfluence others to more forward and I feel Tommy Emmanuel is continuing that progress. If that makes him great or he has a greater impact than players of his generation, then that will the measure of his greatness IMHO.
__________________
Martin 000-28EC, Taylor 12fret Cedar/Mahogany, Taylor GC8, Carvin AC275, Takamine TC135SC, Yamaha APX5na |
#48
|
|||
|
|||
More randomness from me, jerry Reed and Chet do some really good duets. Like the record Jerry and Me, Stump Water is amazing.... Too bad it isnt on youtube, or I'd post it...
|
#49
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
It's "Me and Jerry" . . and there was another album called (aptly) "Me and Chet". Fortunately, they've got the pair out now as a CD (both albums on one CD). I found mine at Ernest Tubb's in Ft. Worth. I'm sure they still have it online. |
#50
|
|||
|
|||
Using superlatives in music is no different than using them in art. They make no sense. Was Van Gogh "better" than Picasso? Is there any way to measure talent? You can like who you like and that's about all there is to it.
__________________
Taylor 810 Guild J30-12 |
#51
|
|||
|
|||
Tommy is the greatest all around guitarist I've ever seen. He can play the most difficult riff and make it look effortless, but perhaps more importantly he can play the simplest melody so beautifully it can bring tears to your eyes. He's endlessly inventive,soulful and easily the most entertaining live performer of any the "virtuoso" guitarists. He's also an incredible composer with a very impressive catalogue of fantastic original tunes with highly memorable melodies.
I've seen Tommy in concert six times and he always blows me away. I highly recommend every guitarist go see him. If you are new to Tommy I'd recommend his "Only" CD. A classic. For a live performance DVD check out "Live at Sheldon Hall". And finally Tommy has an amazing instructional DVD/VHS called "Up Close".
__________________
My "lefty" guitars... Taylor GS Maple/Spruce Taylor GS Mahogany/Cedar Taylor NS44ce Yamaha APX-5 Fender American Deluxe Strat Tom Anderson Custom Strats (2) The music business is a cruel and shallow money trench. A long plastic hallway where thieves and pimps run free and good men die like dogs. There is also a negative side. -- Hunter S. Thompson |
#52
|
|||
|
|||
|
#53
|
|||
|
|||
With a thread titled the world's greatest, it lends itself to scrutiny. Problem is, music is subjective to personal tatses. I know that all so well from many guitar contests.
Tommy is a gifted player, a gifted entertainer, and as I've had the occasion to meet him, he is a pretty cool fella as well. That being said, I've walked away from his shows at festivals numerous times. It just isn't my cup of tea. That doesn't mean to say that I don't think he can play. But I have to say that I heard so much hype that when I finally saw his performance, it was a disappointment to me. Probably didn't help matters that it was on the same bill as Phil Keaggy, who is just a lot more musical to me. Now, if we're discussing 'greatness' in the context of influence, not just in admiration, I think Tommy's legacy will include that, but I don't think it's to that level yet. For my money, Django would have to be the greatest, ever. And that includes his influence on most every 'great' player mentioned so far. And just think if he'd had ALL of his fingers. |
#54
|
|||
|
|||
One of the great difficulties of being a solo acoustic guitar player is the very large number of people out there who consider music to be "repetitive" if they hear two songs in a row with no words in them.
|
#55
|
|||
|
|||
I too find the statement that TE;s music lacks emotion to be mind-boggling - if anything, his songs are all about feeling and emotion.
Like another person who posted, although I am slack jawed at his skill at the technically pyrotechnical songs, I actually prefer his more melodic and slower pieces like "Those who wait" and "Morning Aire" - such beautiful melodies that stir the soul and impart a lift to anyone who listens. In music, it is not possible to call someone "the Greatest", IMHO because it is so subjective. In terms of technical skill, TE in anyone's book has got to be world class, able to at least match any acoutic guitarist in the world today. In terms of melodically beautiful song composing, he has to rank pretty high too. In terms of entertainment, most everyone agrees he is a terrific entertainer and holds the stage superbly. The one concert I attended, even non-guitarists who initially did not expect to be enthralled by it, I oculd hear them praising him and really enjoying themselves. I think most of us can agree that in any grouping of the world's greatest guitarists, TE would rate a place on that list in almost any objective person's estimation. |
#56
|
|||
|
|||
Cbango--
Thanks for the youtube link with James Burton, Chet Atkins and Albert Lee. It's been a long time since I've seen Albert Lee, one of my all time favorites. I saw him as the guitarist for Emmylou Harris in a small theatre in Seattle many years ago. One of the greatest performances I've ever seen. -Kev
__________________
1976 Guild D-55 SB, 2002 Martin DCME, 1975 Takamine F-385 (12 string), cheap old 1967 Giannini model 6 classical, 70's Aria O-73 classical, Yamaha G55....and a whole lot of electrics. |
#57
|
||||
|
||||
I'm with Pistolero on this one. Django was great, and jazz is not even my cup of tea.
__________________
Musically yours, Woody Boyd Luthier "Home of the banjo eating HOG" |
#58
|
|||
|
|||
Quote:
The title is all well and good but what does it really mean? That Lenny Breau was somehow less regarded by Chet?
__________________
Gerry |
#59
|
|||
|
|||
[QUOTE=Pistolero;1182038]With a thread titled the world's greatest, it lends itself to scrutiny. Problem is, music is subjective to personal tastes.
Of course that is correct...to title anyone "the greatest" anything is completely subjective and opinionated. for instance ,, im not as skilled a flatpicker as Alan Shadd, but im a much better player than Eric Clapton... Just because nobody agrees with me, at least on the Clapton part makes no difference to me.. I like fiddle tunes and dislike rock...hmm go figure... Rick |
#60
|
|||
|
|||
Chet honored Tommy for a reason
Quote:
Thanks for this ... I absolutely agree with you. Chet also coached and work closely with Tommy, took him under his wing. He recognised him a a young prodigy. Tommy is doing similar work with young talented artists. For those of you have to see Tommy live - its jaw dropping. (Note I am not a promoter or in any way connected to Tommy, I'm someone who gave an independent interview/review). |