Misi Trio Air vs. Schatten HFN pickup comparison

[Heinrich]

Hello Acoustic guitar forum members,

After being tired with my Misi Motif that presented this dreaded quack sound I asked my local luthier to build a HFN Schatten into my Santa Cruz and a Misi Trio Air into my McIlroy. Sure enough this yields quite different results, but the different character of these two pickups can easily be recognised. Will have to decide which one to build into my three guitars. Both excellent pickups but I am leaning a tad more towards the Schatten.

Let me know what you think. Here is the link:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfiUattSH6Y