Time for a separate Carbon Guitar section?

[PTC Bernie]

Ok, let's hear your opinions. Is it time for the carbon crowd to have their own section?

[Doubleneck]

I think that's the section you are in?

[Acousticado]

Originally Posted by PTC Bernie

Ok, let's hear your opinions. Is it time for the carbon crowd to have their own section?

Huh???????

[ChunkyB]

I'm guessing he posted this in the main section, and the mods moved it here.

[mchalebk]

Bernie, I don't see any CF guitars in your signature yet. What's the holdup?

I would assume, by the time you see these responses, that you now know we already have a CF forum here. So, looking for some CF info? This is the place to ask.

[dkoloff]

Originally Posted by PTC Bernie

Ok, let's hear your opinions. Is it time for the carbon crowd to have their own section?

If you want us to have a second section we can ask........

[kramster]

A CF section within a CF section...deep...just sayin'

[RP]

Originally Posted by PTC Bernie

Ok, let's hear your opinions. Is it time for the carbon crowd to have their own section?

WOW! Deja vue.....

[short bald guy]

Correct me if I have erred....But this is the Acoustic Guitar Forum, and are not carbon fiber guitars also acoustic guitars? I really do not think we need to classify these instruments as anything other than acoustic guitars.
And, while on the subject, there are (in my opinion) some advantages to having a carbon fiber guitar, but it was the sound that the resulted in my being drawn to them. I know that this may not be the case for all owners. Just saying.........

[wcap]

Originally Posted by kramster

A CF section within a CF section...deep...just sayin'

Accessible only by those who know the secret handshake.

[ishtar]

Maybe we should establish a metaforum to talk about the carbon fiber forum? Someone should start a thread.

[RP]

Originally Posted by short bald guy

Correct me if I have erred....But this is the Acoustic Guitar Forum, and are not carbon fiber guitars also acoustic guitars? I really do not think we need to classify these instruments as anything other than acoustic guitars..........

This was all heavily debated last year after the creation of a separate Carbon Fiber Guitar subforum on AGF...

[mc1]

maybe he meant a subforum strictly for carbon guitars, as opposed to carbon fiber guitars.

or maybe he meant, "is it time?", like was it established too early.

(just teasing ptc bernie - - i've done the same thing)

Originally Posted by ishtar

Maybe we should establish a metaforum to talk about the carbon fiber forum? Someone should start a thread.

i like the idea of a whole series of metaforums to discuss all the subforums, and maybe even a meta-meta forum to discuss the metaforums.

by moving the metaquestion here, to the carbon fiber subforum, it has removed the meta-ness of it. i think it should go to open mic, where it would have a completely different meaning.

i'll spent the rest of my morning thinking about this...

[kramster]

Never meta carbon fiber forum I didn't like... just meta-tating

[RP]

Originally Posted by mc1

maybe he meant a subforum strictly for carbon guitars, as opposed to carbon fiber guitars.

or maybe he meant, "is it time?", like was it established too early.

(just teasing ptc bernie - - i've done the same thing)



i like the idea of a whole series of metaforums to discuss all the subforums, and maybe even a meta-meta forum to discuss the metaforums.

by moving the metaquestion here, to the carbon fiber subforum, it has removed the meta-ness of it. i think it should go to open mic, where it would have a completely different meaning.

i'll spent the rest of my morning thinking about this...

A slow morning in the Maritimes, ay???