Anthem vs Amulet

[aaronmarkson]

These are two of my favorite pickup systems right now, so I did a little comparison/review video on them and what they sound like going direct, through a PA, with and without EQ.

Which do you like?

[AeroUSA]

These are also two of my favorites right now. I would be happy with either but I do like that the Trance has nothing in the Sound hole.

[rockabilly69]

In my guitars, I prefer the Trance, although it does need a bit of reverb on it to give it some air.

[Petty1818]

In that video, it really shows how much more natural the Anthem is. Where the Amulet really falls apart IMO is with strumming. It very much brings out the piezo quality of it and since I strum a lot in my one band, it really didn't work. I find there's a big difference between a demo where someone strums vs. strumming live.

Unfortunately, neither pickup really worked for me but I think with pedals like the Voiceprint and Tonedexter out, it makes sense to go for the least invasive installation and then blend in some IR's.

[cvmatt247]

Thanks for the awesome video, Aaron! I had the Trance in a couple of Gibson's and it didn't sound nearly as good as yours. Also have used the Anthem in many guitars and for me its the best sounding aftermarket pickup, but I absolutely hate having that cream colored monster control unit in the sound hole. I know they have the smaller SL, but that one bugs me too. So picky. I really wish they'd find a way to make the controls less visible like Fishman (and most everyone else) does.

[Cuki79]

Originally Posted by cvmatt247

I know they have the smaller SL, but that one bugs me too. So picky. I really wish they'd find a way to make the controls less visible like Fishman (and most everyone else) does.

Why don't you just do that mod on the SL? (here a picture I made with the Lyric control)

I don't think the plastic box has any electrical function...



Note that this is a mod that is 100% reversible. You can remove the double tape. Clean the gluer left-over, stick the controller back in the box very easily.

my 2 cents,
Cuki

[cvmatt247]

Originally Posted by Cuki79

Why don't you just do that mod on the SL? (here a picture I made with the Lyric control)

I don't think the plastic box has any electrical function...



Note that this is a mod that is 100% reversible. You can remove the double tape. Clean the gluer left-over, stick the controller back in the box very easily.

my 2 cents,
Cuki

That’s brilliant! Might have to give that a try.

[aaronmarkson]

Originally Posted by Petty1818

I think with pedals like the Voiceprint and Tonedexter out, it makes sense to go for the least invasive installation and then blend in some IR's.

I plan to do some IR creation and testing soon!!

Originally Posted by cvmatt247

Thanks for the awesome video, Aaron! I had the Trance in a couple of Gibson's and it didn't sound nearly as good as yours. Also have used the Anthem in many guitars and for me its the best sounding aftermarket pickup, but I absolutely hate having that cream colored monster control unit in the soundhole. I know they have the smaller SL, but that one bugs me too. So picky. I really wish they'd find a way to make the controls less visible like Fishman (and most everyone else) does.

One big advantage of the Anthem is the very forgiving installation. While I had fairly easy success with my Trance install, that seems to not always be the case.

And I am with you on the big control unit being an eyesore.

Originally Posted by Cuki79

Why don't you just do that mod on the SL?
Cuki

This is a great idea for the SL. Not sure it would work for the full anthem. I wonder if even changing from the cream color to this darker color would help it hide. Are these darker faux tortoiseshell control cover plates available for purchase?

[RogerPease]

That is a pretty cool mod! I'm with you, aaronmarkson, the faux tortise would look nicer.

A mod I've wanted to try is to replace the Tru-mic level pot (not the volume pot) with a
3-turn pot or maybe even a 10-turn unit to make it less touchy to adjust. I wasn't sure
one could pull the sound hole unit apart, but now I see that you can! Thanks, Cuki!

_Roger

[Cuki79]

Originally Posted by aaronmarkson

This is a great idea for the SL. Not sure it would work for the full anthem. I wonder if even changing from the cream color to this darker color would help it hide. Are these darker faux tortoiseshell control cover plates available for purchase?

Knowing Baggs top notch service I would not be surprised if they give you one for free if you ask kindly..