View Single Post
  #18  
Old 06-11-2019, 03:10 PM
Stomp Stomp is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: DUB HAM ORD
Posts: 348
Default

Shifting the tuning around to suit the situation is common practise, but you need to be familiar with the flaws in Equal temperament and how Just Intonation works.

Take a bluegrass band as an example, the fiddler will often tune the open G straight and stack perfect fifths on that G (701.9 cent intervals instead of Equally tempered 700 cents), making the open E string sharp of ET by 5.7 cents.
Out of tune? Not really, as fiddlers say "better sharp than out of tune" (Sweetener FDL).
A concert violinist will tune differently with the A string tuned "straight" and the others tuned in perfect fifths above and below the A (Sweetener VLN).

The Dobro player will invariably lower the B strings by the full 13.7 cents to get a pure beatless third (Sweetener DB0).
Does he worry about "blending in"? No, it's about sounding good - he just watches when he plays what, those sweet triads are worth it.

The banjo player will also lower the B string a smidge (about halfway between an Equally tempered third and a Just intoned third - Sweetener BJO).

Then there's pedal steel, with three different pitches for F# etc. (Sweeteners SE9, SC6 etc.)

It's all about having your instrument sound as good as possible within itself while being aware of the general tonal center of what's being played.
Equal temperament is a distant object in the rearview mirror at that stage...it's a good basis, sure, but trust your ears.
What sounds good to you is probably going to sound good to others too, just be aware of how tuning works.

Our tuners are just the programmable assistants which can show you visually how to get to what your ears want to hear, when your ears can't hear (e.g. on stage).
Purely IMHO of course .
__________________
95 Ditson
56 Gibson LG1
72 Guild D25
77 Gurian JM
78 Yamaha FG375S
79 Guild F512
92 Dobro 33H
96 Guild JF55
00 Fender Tele
01 Gibson Chet Atkins CEC
03 Taylor BB
04 Gibson ES137
05 Washburn Uke
06 Martin DC Aura
06 Gibson LP Std
07 Martin BP
11 Höfner Bs
15 Gibson LP Jr
18 Gibson SJ200
19 Danelectro 12
19 Gretsch G2420T
20 Epiphone Casino

I work for Peterson Strobe Tuners
Reply With Quote