[davidd]

Originally Posted by Brooklyn Bob

So like most of us here I am always on the hunt for the 'next' one. I already have a D18 but I seem to gravitate towards a J45 when I'm out test-driving. I know I am the final judge but is there enough of a difference between the two to justify adding a J45 to the herd?

Yes, very different animals IMO. I have both. My D18 has a much bigger output, much more bass, more harmonics and overtones and is generally a more direct instrument. The longer scale gives it a stiffer feel.

My J45 is drier, balanced, more quiet and much better for vocals. The shorter scale gives a much softer feel and also makes it a more comfortable guitar, especially when seated.

They both could certainly be used for anything you throw at them but they have different personalities.