It would be tool for the job only considerations in my case...If no gigging in my life (which there is not) then no electronics, otherwise there would be...simple as that...
Having said this, I kinda like the simplicity and cleanliness of no electronics generally speaking...
Not that its a big deal anyway in the case of most members here...You all seem to have a thousand guitars anyway, so in practical terms there should be no issue with having both as needed