Swampy, Welcome to the AGF!
Regarding playability, acoustics can be setup to your preference so consider that. Tonewise, did you prefer the Gibson or the Martin?
Go to as many shops as you can and play as many guitars as you can. That will help you make a determination. Don't just play J-45s and D-18s because you never know what might peak your interest. You've got a great budget so you'll be able to get a great guitar.
As mentioned, are there a lot of guitar shops in your area? It's worth it to take a 3 hour road trip to a great shop if you can.
|