Between fretboard radius and nutwidth. . .
. . . which one is more important to you in terms of playability and feel?
|
Quote:
|
nut width is the most important to me.
I prefer a small radius, but if the width is wide enough I can get by. |
Radius and nut width aren't important to me. A comfortable neck profile is my #1 priority.
|
Quote:
If it's on a guitar being made for me, EVERY spec holds separate, but equal importance. Sorry that I can't answer your question as posed. Regards, Howard Emerson |
Quote:
Best, Jayne |
Neither is as important as the tone of the instrument.
|
Nut width determines how cleanly I can play and individual note; radius determines how easily I can play barre chords. Since I don't want to compromise on either of those things, both specs are equally important.
Quote:
|
Quote:
But a big part of the tone comes from the way we play and how easy (or hard) it's for us. We may play an instrument which can sound great with others and bad with us (or viceversa) and one of the reasons is how we feel the instrument. |
Neck radius and shape is more important to me than nut width. (It took me three guitars to figure this out.)
|
[QUOTE=jim1960;6246599]Nut width determines how cleanly I can play and individual note; radius determines how easily I can play barre chords. Since I don't want to compromise on either of those things, both specs are equally important.
Tell me about radius and barre chords. Flatter board = easier or more difficult to barre? I'm new to this level of technicality! And barre chords! Thanks! |
Probably radius.
I can go back and forth between a 6-string and a 12-string pretty easy, and don't tend to notice a 1/16 of an inch or so. Anything tighter than 15" radius I find pretty difficult to play though. |
1. Nut Width. On a flat-top in which I'd play my normal style - 1 & 13/16" but 1 & 7/8" fine. 1& 3/4" on archtops
2. String spacing - 2 & 3/8" is ideal, 2 & 5/16" on short scale, 2 & 1/4" on archtops. 3. Profile, soft "mod-V" or C profile. 4. Camber - not particular. It took me a long time to find a fretboard geometry that really suited me. |
I think I'm fairly insensitive to either, given I can't feel the difference between my 16", 1 & 11/16 gs mini and my 12" 1.75 hummingbird.
I notice scale length the most out of all the neck measurements. I really dont like 25.5. After a lifetime of playing les pauls it feel like playing a bass to me, though I'm sure I'd get used to it quickly enough if I had to |
Quote:
|
The radius doesn’t seem to matter. My guitars have a pretty wide range: 14” radius SCGC, 14" - 26" compound radius Collings, and 20” radius Froggy Bottom. They all barre equally well. I do seem to prefer 1-3/4” nut and 2-1/4 string spacing.
|
Nut width and then string spacing, if forced to prioritize.
I don't find a skinny neck helpful for my old fingers, but I rarely find a neck that hinders my playing anywhere near as much as uncomfortable nut width/string spacing. Of course if I'm spending my money it better have all three. |
Quote:
|
That said, nut width is always 1-3/4” for me...:) |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:12 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, The Acoustic Guitar Forum