The Acoustic Guitar Forum

The Acoustic Guitar Forum (https://www.acousticguitarforum.com/forums/index.php)
-   Acoustic Amplification (https://www.acousticguitarforum.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   How to deal with boomy notes which cause clipping in amp? (https://www.acousticguitarforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=621666)

Odedi 07-24-2021 01:45 PM

How to deal with boomy notes which cause clipping in amp?
 
So my G note gets pretty boomy because of the guitar's main air resonance.
I noticed that while playing outside today, that note can spike up the volume/frequency which then causes clipping in my amp.

I was wondering if any of you are familiar with this issue?
Is there a way to control the offending note's frequency,
So that it doesnt stand out and clip my signal?

YamahaGuy 07-24-2021 03:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6771259)
So my G note gets pretty boomy because of the guitar's main air resonance.
I noticed that while playing outside today, that note can spike up the volume/frequency which then causes clipping in my amp.

I was wondering if any of you are familiar with this issue?
Is there a way to control the offending note's frequency,
So that it doesnt stand out and clip my signal?

Which G? On the bass string? Is it just G, or is it any note played on that particular string. With an under saddle pickup, commonly the low E and/or high e strings are out of balance due to there being more downforce on the saddle and consequently on the pickup at the ends.

Let's first find out why, then we can work on the how.

To answer your question, some EQs are capable of "pulling out" a note out of the signal, so it can be done.

I suspect your pickup is not evenly balanced across the strings...

Cuki79 07-24-2021 03:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6771259)
So my G note gets pretty boomy because of the guitar's main air resonance.
I noticed that while playing outside today, that note can spike up the volume/frequency which then causes clipping in my amp.

I was wondering if any of you are familiar with this issue?
Is there a way to control the offending note's frequency,
So that it doesnt stand out and clip my signal?

You need a Parametric EQ to tame it. Add a sharp cut at 100 Hz.

Odedi 07-25-2021 01:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YamahaGuy (Post 6771317)
Which G? On the bass string? Is it just G, or is it any note played on that particular string. With an under saddle pickup, commonly the low E and/or high e strings are out of balance due to there being more downforce on the saddle and consequently on the pickup at the ends.

Let's first find out why, then we can work on the how.

To answer your question, some EQs are capable of "pulling out" a note out of the signal, so it can be done.

I suspect your pickup is not evenly balanced across the strings...

The open G is quite boomy,
But also the G note on the 4th (D) string on the (5th fret).

The boominess is there also when I am unplugged.
It's just a guitar resonance thing I guess, which gets amplified when amplified hehe

shufflebeat 07-25-2021 02:54 AM

That's what soundhole plugs are designed for.

https://reverb-res.cloudinary.com/im...bj9h3p2rft.jpg

There may be other issues and valuable solutions which others have described in your situation but if chamber resonance is the main one then a decent f/bb will get you most of the way there.

YamahaGuy 07-25-2021 04:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6771510)
The open G is quite boomy,
But also the G note on the 4th (D) string on the (5th fret).

The boominess is there also when I am unplugged.
It's just a guitar resonance thing I guess, which gets amplified when amplified hehe

G2 and G3 are at 98hz and 196hz, respectively. So an eq with 100 and 200hz settings could possibly help to cut those frequencies out. The LR Baggs PADI has a notch filter that can be dialed in for particular notes as well.

Good luck with it.

Odedi 07-25-2021 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shufflebeat (Post 6771525)
That's what soundhole plugs are designed for.

https://reverb-res.cloudinary.com/im...bj9h3p2rft.jpg

There may be other issues and valuable solutions which others have described in your situation but if chamber resonance is the main one then a decent f/bb will get you most of the way there.

Yeah I am using that.
The boomy note was A before I put on this cover.
Now it's G hehe

James May 07-25-2021 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6771786)
Yeah I am using that.
The boomy note was A before I put on this cover.
Now it's G hehe

Reducing the sound hole area will lower the chamber resonance frequency. I'm surprised it isn't lower than G (98Hz) with the sound hole completely covered.

shufflebeat 07-25-2021 02:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6771786)
Yeah I am using that.
The boomy note was A before I put on this cover.
Now it's G hehe

Ok, need more info:

Guitar (type/model)
Pickup (type/model)
Preamp/EQ
Amp model
Typical performance environmemt
Existing tools available (EQ pedals, cement mixer, etc.)

Cuki79 07-25-2021 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YamahaGuy (Post 6771540)
G2 and G3 are at 98hz and 196hz, respectively. So an eq with 100 and 200hz settings could possibly help to cut those frequencies out. The LR Baggs PADI has a notch filter that can be dialed in for particular notes as well.

Good luck with it.

Agree with YamahaGuy, a notch filter will work.

calvanesebob 07-25-2021 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6771510)
The boominess is there also when I am unplugged. hehe

Have you had the nut and saddle checked?

Odedi 07-26-2021 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by James May (Post 6771846)
Reducing the sound hole area will lower the chamber resonance frequency. I'm surprised it isn't lower than G (98Hz) with the sound hole completely covered.

Oh, that's because I have a small soundport on the upper side !
I should try and cover that too,
however I am afraid it will kill the tone.

Odedi 07-26-2021 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by calvanesebob (Post 6771961)
Have you had the nut and saddle checked?

Can you tell me more?
What needs to be checked there?

Odedi 07-26-2021 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shufflebeat (Post 6771885)
Ok, need more info:

Guitar (type/model)
Pickup (type/model)
Preamp/EQ
Amp model
Typical performance environmemt
Existing tools available (EQ pedals, cement mixer, etc.)

Cordoba GK studio Negra
Fishman Presys Blend (mic + ust)
Fishman loudbox mini charge
Sometimes at homes, sometimes on the street busking.
Got a small 7EQ pedal - Ammoon 3C where the 1k frequency is lowered drastically because it just sounds like **** lol

MarkF_48 07-26-2021 09:49 AM

How close is the amp placed near you and is it in front of you, to the side, or behind? Set fairly high in volume?
Have you tried some distance between you and the amp?

EZYPIKINS 07-26-2021 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cuki79 (Post 6771323)
You need a Parametric EQ to tame it. Add a sharp cut at 100 Hz.

A decent mixer has a lo cut switch usually at 100 hz for just this problem.

Also a feedback buster will knock this down as well.

shufflebeat 07-26-2021 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6772375)
...I have a small soundport on the upper side !
I should try and cover that too,
however I am afraid it will kill the tone.

And also

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6772382)
Fishman Presys Blend (mic + ust)

I believe are key to your solution.

Odedi 07-26-2021 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MarkF_48 (Post 6772403)
How close is the amp placed near you and is it in front of you, to the side, or behind? Set fairly high in volume?
Have you tried some distance between you and the amp?

Sometimes in front, sometimes behind, sometimes to the side.
And also sometimes its close and sometimea its further away.
It doesnt matter much.

As to volume , I would say it's about medium , maybe a little more

Odedi 07-26-2021 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shufflebeat (Post 6772492)
And also



I believe are key to your solution.

Hey, what do you suggest regarding the pickup?

ljguitar 07-26-2021 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6772375)
Oh, that's because I have a small soundport on the upper side !
I should try and cover that too,
however I am afraid it will kill the tone.

Hi Odedi

I've got small side ports on two guitars, and they do not affect feedback that I've ever detected (and I play in bands with the main soundhole covered).



As mentioned, pitch specific, escalating, overpowering frequencies can best be controlled with parametric EQ, or distancing one's self from the source of the guitar hearing itself.

If it's triggered by a stage monitor, the monitor can be turned down or moved. If by a personal stage amplifier, then reposition it to behind yourself so your body shields the guitar from it. I run stage amps knee to waist high and 4-6 feet behind me. My body shields the guitar's body from hearing itself.

If it's being triggered by the mains you may have to move away from the speaker proximity some. If there are subs, sound techs seem to want to run them very hot and pump the bass into the room at decibel levels which trigger feedback in audience members as well as guitars.

This is a major source of feedback for acoustic guitars.

Also depending on the sophistication of one's gear, or the PA board capability, you may be able to deal with it by notching it out.

Most digital boards can produce quite narrow notches, and my ToneDexter with the latest update now identifies and isolates the likely frequencies to 'sing' (howl) and pre-assigns them to the notch filter.

Here is a string by string (1st string-treble) at top going down to the bass. Even though it's not listed, if you are in dropped D, the low D would be around 73Hz (cycles per second).


I have a simpler chart somewhere which lists only the open strings, and if I can find it, I'll post it. They are usually the culprits anyway.

EDIT Found it… EDIT


Added both of these to my 'favorites' in my phone photos just now…

Hope this helps the discussion…





shufflebeat 07-26-2021 09:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6772586)
Hey, what do you suggest regarding the pickup?

First the soundholes.

The soundhole plug prevents a strong bass resonance building up in the structure of the body. It's similar to the difference between ported speakers/monitors which use escaping (and returning) air to simulate a much bigger cabinet (most cheap monitors) and "infinite baffle" (sealed boxes) which are either small and lacking bass or full range and huge (ye olde Yamaha ns10/Kef 103.2).

In some respects it doesn't matter where the air is flowing in and out of, the plug is not doing it's job as designed. Now, you may be lucky and hit on the perfect balance of killing your problem resonance without sealing the box but I think that's unlikely.

If you seal the small port you will lose some *acoustic* bass but if you don't you'll have to filter it out electronically anyway to avoid feedback so swings/roundabouts. I suspect if you can kill the acoustic resonance you can ramp up the amplified bass to more than compensate...

...except ...for the mic.

I don't know the Presys Blend. Does the EQ work on UST, mic or both after they've been blended? I've seen various combinations over the years.

It would be useful to know if there is one element of the system (UST vs mic) which is responsible for the booming. If it were me I would cover the port with something of significant mass, kill the mic for the time being and see how hard you can push the volume without losing it. It may not sound pretty but knowing the result of this will inform the next step.

calvanesebob 07-26-2021 10:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odedi (Post 6772377)
Can you tell me more?
What needs to be checked there?

I'm no expert but maybe if the saddle is not sitting perfectly flat in the bridge, it my have more/less pressure under certain strings making them louder. Same with the nut.

just seems odd that it is louder on certain notes unplugged too.

Br1ck 07-27-2021 04:55 PM

Run into this sort of thing at an open mic I help with. Our mixer has a built in compressor. Dialing in some compression usually smooths the hot spike. This is the quick and dirty on the fly solution.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:23 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, The Acoustic Guitar Forum

vB Ad Management by =RedTyger=