NGD: Martin D-28 Marquis (pics added to post #1):

[martingitdave]

UPDATE: The Collings guitar I originally purchased did not work out for me. I exchanged it for a new Martin D-28 Marquis.

My shopping criteria:

Used or New
C.F. Martin
Pre war scalloped bracing
Red Spruce
Madagascar rosewood
Big (full spectrum) tone!
Dreadnought shape
1-3/4" nut width
Slim neck
Factory pickup system

What I bought:

New
C.F. Martin
Pre war scalloped bracing
Red Spruce
EIR
Big (full spectrum) tone!
Dreadnought shape
1-3/4" nut width
Modified V
K&K Ultra Pure Active System

Basically, I've played a lot of dreads the past few weeks. I picked the one that acoustically sounded the best to me.

I bought a 2016 Martin D-28 Marquis. I'm updating the thread as I make minor modifications and get the pickup sorted out.

UPDATE: I installed, and will subsequently remove, the Lyric internal microphone. While it is a very nice system, it is not a good fit for this model. The mid range with the red spruce top on this guitar seems to be too present through the Lyric. There is no way to EQ this on the guitar's preamp, which is an important feature for quick sound check situations.



I was deciding between the redesigned K&K UltraPure system and the Trance Amulet M system. After scouring the installation manuals and watching demos of both systems, I decided on the K&K solution. I've installed these many times and the results are good and predictable. I expect the sensors to be permanent and the internal preamp replaceable as they miniaturize and improve the design. With these well tested SBTs and their internally applied XLR Prue preamp, I expect to get great tone. I had the mini in my HD28V and used the external XLR preamp and it was great. I just don't want to use the belt pack or pedals any more.

I'll have 3 band EQ, phase and a low batt indicator too.

I've had a chance to play the guitar with the Lyric system installed and it did not degrade the tone one bit. This system should be no different.



UPDATE 2: I installed the K&K UltraPure system. It sounded terrific. But the unit did not physically fit well with the bracing around the sound hole. So, I looked at a number of internal preamp options from K&K, D-TAR, Mi-Si, and Schatten. Ultimately, I read some of the threads regarding the D-TAR multi-source system and decided to mod it to work with the installed K&K. The results are even better than the UltraPure. The mic gives it the extra "air" that pickups can't reproduce. When I run the pickup system through the TC Play Acoustic pedal, the available reverb, chorus, and body rez effects add some beauty to the tone.



Read about it here: http://www.acousticguitarforum.com/f...d.php?t=439594


Other than the pickup, the modifications will be minimal. I've had a strap button installed on the heel. Unfortunately, I don't really care for the tuning machines. There is considerable slop with the gears, where small/fine turns the peg with not result in immediate turning of the gear. I am installing the redesigned Grover Sta Tites 18:1 in nickel. I considered Waverlies, which I like, but I had a great experience with the Grovers on my last guitar. Evidently, the were designed in consultation with SCGC. They are less than 1/3 the cost of Waverlies.



UPDATE: The Grover Sta-Tites are nice, but stick a little. I decided to try the following 18:1 open back tuners from the Larrivee Company.



The pics below were taken by the store. I will provide my own soon. Thanks to the guys at CME who were very accommodating. Their prices are reasonable, and it's great to have such a huge selection to put your hands on before you buy.

[TJNies]

Originally Posted by martingitdave

I hope I can finally stop this guitar acquisition nonsense.

C'mon, who are you trying to kid?

jk; congrats on the new Collings!

[Treenewt]

Congrats! That sounds like a fantastic Collings! I hope it's everything you want it to be!

[Dwight]

Nice going, Can't wait to see the pictures!

[PTC Bernie]

Originally Posted by martingitdave

I'm getting a new guitar. No, I don't need another guitar.

Congrats!

And, what does "Need" have to do with anything?

[mkitman]

Nice; also looking forward to pictures~!

[pjroberts]

Wow, congrats! I'm keen to see how this works for you since the next dread I zeroed in on is that same '37 D28A, particularly because of the 1 ¾ neck. My previous Tony Rice was almost perfect, minus the 1 11/16 neck. But I'm most wary of the Authenitic neck. Just got my OM-18A set up with lower action bridge side to make. up for this, and that is to be my experiment. But, you can't go wrong with a Collings if the tone suits. I may have to try one out .... especially if I could find the wider neck.

Can't wait to see your pix and initial thoughts.

[brencat]

Collings dreads are awesome, and I love style 3 also.

Congratulations and please post pictures when you get her!

[martingitdave]

Does anyone have any anecdotal information regarding style 3? I'm a Collings noob. I did find out it is actually 1-3/4" nut. That's why it didn't feel different.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

[brencat]

Originally Posted by martingitdave

Does anyone have any anecdotal information regarding style 3? I'm a Collings noob. I did find out it is actually 1-3/4" nut. That's why it didn't feel different.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

Nicer wood (but all Collings wood is nice), arrow back strip, no fretboard markers, ivoroid bound neck and headstock, and gold Waverlies

[christoph.penny]

Congrats, I've ordered a preamp pickup box of tricks you fit to your guitary myself, it's on the slow boat from Hong Kong as we speak,

Sent from my XT1021 using Tapatalk

[Glennwillow]

Congratulations Dave!

The Collings D3A really is a great sounding guitar. I particularly like the light shade burst that Collings is using with the herringbone trim.

- Glenn

[martingitdave]

I picked the guitar up after work. Had my first gig this evening. The verdict... It's going back... It is one of the best flat picking guitars I've played. But, unfortunately, it does not accompany my voice very well. I'm more than a little embarrassed and disappointed that I can't keep an otherwise stunning guitar.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

[gfsark]

Wow, that was quick. Better to cut your losses than to hang onto something that won't work. But how did the guitar not work with your voice?

[TBman]

Sorry to hear that, but just think, the hunt continues!!