Your Song Sucks

[Ken C]

Originally Posted by 66strummer

But when people post recordings of their songs on the AGF aren't they actually doing just that (asking "How do you like my song")? Or would that be different because we dont all know each other personally? I mean NO, People dont generally post something and ask how others like it, but they DO almost always ask for feedback (which to me is the same thing basically).

Yes, that is what is being done here but some folks may think the readers are more qualified listeners and being fellow performers, that might make a difference. Though it should make no difference whether we know each other or not. I wouldn't want to hurt anyone's feelings.

I guess what is being looked for here is some objectivity in a totally subjective endeavor. <g>

I wouldn't post a song for criticism, though I have a website that is for the sharing of songs, not critique. <g>

Ken C.