The Acoustic Guitar Forum

Go Back   The Acoustic Guitar Forum > General Acoustic Guitar and Amplification Discussion > Other Musical Instruments

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1  
Old 02-21-2012, 08:08 PM
Riperoo Riperoo is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Posts: 50
Default Thinking about picking up the Banjo, looking for some input

OK, old guy, getting ready to pounce on the half a century mark. Have been playing the Guitar, mostly acoustic for about 10 years, and I am somewhat competent, I can butcher any number of songs. I am really drawn to that down home sound of the banjo, so thinking about grabbing one just for fun. BTW, all my playing is for fun, I don't gig, other than with my kids, my playing is strictly back porch strumming. So, my questions.

How hard to transition from a guitar to a banjo? Guitar is my only insrtrument, I am for the most part self taught, some lessons, but mostly on line and you tube. I am never gonna rock the world but I know enough to be dangerous. Basic music skills and know enought to keep me happy.

What about a 6 string banjo? The Bantar or Guitjo, or what ever they call it, can I get the same sound out of that as out of a regular ol 5 string banjo?

Any and all input greatly appreciated.
__________________
Fender Telecaster 1992
Taylor GA-RS 1995
Martin Backpacker 2004
Squier Telecaster 2010
Taylor GS Mini 2011
Hot Rod Old School Resonator 2012
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 02-21-2012, 09:10 PM
matonman matonman is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: mackay queensland /australia on the great barrier reef
Posts: 307
Default

g'day riperoo, i took up the banjo a while ago after "playing" guitar for a long time and i found it a different beast indeed, its easy enough too get used to the basic chord shapes and if you have fingerpicked a bit ,but if you want to play bluegrass scrugs style it takes a while to get your fingers going correctly and getting that bounce,im still not there ,but i havent been applying myself lately since i got my mandolin,which i have found much easier .
i love the sound of the banjo as well so i understand where you are coming from so if you havn't got your heart set on a banjo ,i would look at a mandolin,its, imo a much easier transition but having said that it cant hurt to have....both!
as far as the banjitar goes ive never played one, perhaps taylor swift could chime in
__________________
yamaha fg420 [1985]
mandel om
yamaha cg 151
maton em225ce
martin 00016gt
greg bennett 5 string banjo
epiphone a style mandolin
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 02-21-2012, 09:22 PM
Riperoo Riperoo is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Posts: 50
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by matonman View Post
g'day riperoo, i took up the banjo a while ago after "playing" guitar for a long time and i found it a different beast indeed, its easy enough too get used to the basic chord shapes and if you have fingerpicked a bit ,but if you want to play bluegrass scrugs style it takes a while to get your fingers going correctly and getting that bounce,im still not there ,but i havent been applying myself lately since i got my mandolin,which i have found much easier .
i love the sound of the banjo as well so i understand where you are coming from so if you havn't got your heart set on a banjo ,i would look at a mandolin,its, imo a much easier transition but having said that it cant hurt to have....both!
as far as the banjitar goes ive never played one, perhaps taylor swift could chime in
Thanks Matonman, and I spit my beer on the Taylor Swift reference. Thanks for the info, I would never have thought the Mandolin was an easier transition than the Banjo. That is definitely on my list. Maybe I will have to go there first.
__________________
Fender Telecaster 1992
Taylor GA-RS 1995
Martin Backpacker 2004
Squier Telecaster 2010
Taylor GS Mini 2011
Hot Rod Old School Resonator 2012
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 02-21-2012, 09:59 PM
leftybanjo leftybanjo is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: boerne, tx
Posts: 809
Default

I found the 5 string banjo very difficult, takes many hours to perfect the needed "rolls". I have a 6 string Bantar and it is loud. I bought a 4 string long neck tenor banjo, called a plectrum banjo, and I tune the four strings like the 4 smallest strings on a guitar, some call it Nashville tuning, works and sounds fine and I can use standard guitar chords.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 02-21-2012, 11:32 PM
wcap wcap is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 4,414
Default

I went the other direction: I was an obsessive, compulsive 5-string banjo player for close to 30 years before becoming an obsessive compulsive fingerstyle/classical guitar player (which started about 8 years ago).

I'm a banjo snob, and I tend to view 5-string banjos as the real deal, and everything else as being inferior. OK, yes, tenor banjos are legitimate instruments (but really, whole different beasts), as are 6 string banjos (I guess), but a 5-string banjo is something special that presents some unique opportunities that other (inferior ) forms of banjo lack. A 6-string banjo could probably be a a lot of fun, but if you want a really genuine, traditional banjo sound I don't think you are going to get this without a 5-string banjo. If you want to sound like Pete Seeger or Earl Scruggs or Tony Trischka or Bela Fleck, get a 5 string banjo. If you want to play Foggy Mountain Breakdown (like in the Bonnie and Clyde movie) or The Ballad of Jed Clampett (theme song from The Beverly Hillbillies - people love it when I play this), get a 5-string banjo. If you want to sound like the old traditional clawhammer/frailing style players, get a 5-string banjo. Yes, I'm a banjo snob.

A 5-string banjo has very small intervals between the strings (in standard G tuning anyway), and past the 5th fret (which is where the 5th string starts) the 1st and 5th strings are the same note (and past a certain point on the neck most notes can be played in 4 or 5 different places on the neck - I'm talking about the exact same pitch here). This allows for really really smooth runs of notes, which can be played rapidly with a smoothness that is hard to achieve on a guitar - this is the basis of the banjo sound in some styles of playing (e.g. melodic style). In other styles of playing the 5th string is sometimes (or usually) used as a drone string, and this is integral to other sorts of banjo sounds.

When I play guitar I miss the ease of playing smooth chromatic runs and such that can come so naturally on 5-string banjo. When I play banjo, I miss the bass notes and the relative ease with which you can have multiple things going on at once (e.g. in a well developed fingerstyle guitar arrangement).

Any instrument, whether guitar or banjo, is going to take a lot of time before you feel really comfortable and competent. When I first started banjo I played Foggy Mountain Breakdown (Scruggs style) and Cripple Creek (a frailing/clawhammer arrangement) over and over and over and over..........and over and over.......and over and over again, really badly, for about a year. Then I started adding some pieces, which I also played badly. About 2 years and many hours into this things really started to come together, and a lot of things I had been working on and playing badly for some time started to really sound good.

When I started playing fingerstyle guitar in earnest (after decades with banjo), I sounded pretty bad, and felt pretty clumsy for a few years. It was not until I had been at this for about 5 years that I really started to feel I was playing things really well (and I certainly was no beginner when it came to stringed instruments in general).

I don't think banjo is fundamentally any harder than fingerstyle/classical guitar. Due to the nature of the instrument, banjo players tend to play a lot in certain keys (G is "Gods Key" in standard tuning on 5-string banjo, though people also play a lot in C, and D, and there are a variety of alternate tunings that are commonly used, such as C, D, and D minor tuning). Standard tuning on 5-string banjo is an open G chord. Given the fact that a lot of pieces tend to be arranged in a few commonly used keys, and given the narrow neck, and the light strings that many banjo players prefer, the left hand tends to have it easier on 5-string banjo than on guitar. The bigger challenge is in training your right hand (but then when you go back to guitar your guitar playing friends will be amazed by your right hand!).

I see no advantage to playing mandolin first. Play mandolin if you want to play mandolin (I play mandolin too - it is much more like guitar flatpicking than banjo playing). If you are attracted to banjo (a sign of good taste, in my book ), then by all means get a banjo and give it a shot.

I learned with the aid of several main books:

The classic by Pete Seeger:

http://www.amazon.com/5-String-Banjo...bxgy_mov_img_b

Earl Scruggs' classic book:

http://www.amazon.com/Earl-Scruggs-5...9888678&sr=8-2

Tony Trischka's wonderful melodic banjo book (I used an earlier edition of this that I got in about 1980):

http://www.elderly.com/books/items/01-963149.htm

Peter Wernick's Bluegrass Banjo book:

http://www.amazon.com/Bluegrass-Banj.../dp/0825601487


Also, a big collection of banjo arrangements (that might interest you in a few years maybe) can be found here:

http://www.frettedinstrumentsnyc.com

(This is also a mother lode of fantastic fingerstyle guitar arrangements!)


I also had some Flatt and Scruggs records that I listened to a lot (and listened to slowed down to hear better what was going on - the Petticoat Junction theme song sounded pretty funny with the female voices (saying "Petticoat Junction") slowed down and sounding like big burly but rather effeminate men!).

I started out playing a Sears banjo from a Sears outlet store, and played that for about 5 or 6 years before building a much MUCH nicer banjo from a Stewart MacDonald kit. I can't stand to play that old Sears banjo now (but still have it). You don't need a top of the line banjo to learn on, but don't get a piece of junk (like my Sears banjo) either!

Your guitar knowledge will make learning banjo easier, and your guitar skills and sensibilities will enhance your banjo playing. Learning banjo will also enhance and transform what you do on guitar in some very nice ways.

Last edited by wcap; 02-22-2012 at 01:58 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 02-21-2012, 11:53 PM
wcap wcap is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 4,414
Default

By the way, as I said above, many notes on a 5-string banjo can be played in at least 4 (and often 5) different locations on the neck (again, I'm talking about the exact same pitch being playable in 4 or 5 places), and often these locations are not physically all that far apart. What this means is there is usually a really large number of possible ways of fingering a given sequence of notes. Some ways will be impossible to play. Others will be possible but awkward. One or two ways will likely be elegant in their simplicity and efficiency. Playing banjo well comes down, in large part, to discovering those elegantly simple fingerings, without which many things that banjo players play would be darn near impossible. This is one of the reasons why banjo players can often play so fast (though some of my favorite banjo playing is actually the slow stuff - don't fall into the trap of just playing everything on banjo as fast as you can....hotrodding a banjo can be great fun, but if played with finesse, and especially if played slower, a banjo can have a lovely expressive nuanced sound that is wonderful).

So, fingerings are everything on banjo. Well, not everything, but a big part of the battle. Yes, fingerings are a big deal on guitar too, but there are fewer fingering options for a given sequence of notes on guitar.

Consequently, even more so than guitar players, 5-string banjo players tend to LOVE tablature, because it maps out those all important fingerings. Even if I had learned to sight read all the notes on the banjo neck when I first started to play banjo, I would have found it VERY difficult to get competent on banjo without tablature to map out the fingerings for me.

Last edited by wcap; 02-22-2012 at 02:12 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 02-22-2012, 04:19 AM
catdaddy catdaddy is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Backroads of Florida
Posts: 6,427
Default

A lot of great info from wcap there!

I've been playing 5-string banjo for about 3 years now and love it! I learned to play Scruggs style by practicing the various rolls over and over and over.
The most difficult part of that process was getting my ear used to my thumb playing the high 5th string. Having first learned Travis style fingerpicking on guitar I kept experiencing a mental disconnect by expecting to hear an alternating bass pattern coming from my thumb. Once I got used to that the proficiency came fairly easily.

And yes, I'm a banjo snob too so my advice is to stay away from those 6-string banjo 'imposters'. You'll never get an authentic sound from them simply because the picking patterns on one of those will never be the same as on the traditional 5-string banjo.
__________________

AKA 'Screamin' Tooth Parker'


You can listen to Walt's award winning songs with his acoustic band The Porch Pickers @ the Dixie Moon album or rock out electrically with Rock 'n' Roll Reliquary

Bourgeois AT Mahogany D
Gibson Hummingbird
Martin J-15
Voyage Air VAD-04
Martin 000X1AE
Squier Classic Vibe 50s Stratocaster
Squier Classic Vibe Custom Telecaster
PRS SE Standard 24
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 02-22-2012, 05:01 AM
Riperoo Riperoo is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Posts: 50
Default

Wow, great info Wcap, much apprecited. I am definitely leaning towards a five string. I considered a mandolin for about a 1/2 hour, but then I started listening and watching some you tube stuff on both instruments and the banjo is just screaming my name. At some point I will probably wind up with a mandolin as well, but I think you have pushed me over the line with regard to a banjo. Thanks again!
__________________
Fender Telecaster 1992
Taylor GA-RS 1995
Martin Backpacker 2004
Squier Telecaster 2010
Taylor GS Mini 2011
Hot Rod Old School Resonator 2012
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 02-22-2012, 07:35 AM
zabdart zabdart is offline
Guest
 
Join Date: May 2011
Posts: 9,306
Default

From my own experience: First of all, right-hand technique on banjo is entirely different from guitar because of that high drone 5th string. Your brain is going to rebel a little in the beginning. Secondly, it's important to make a decision about what kind of music you want to play on the banjo before purchasing one.
Bluegrass banjo, which is fingerpicked (thumb plays down-strokes, fingers play up-strokes) sounds much better on a banjo with a resonator back. Old-time mountain banjo uses a right-hand technique called frailing, in which both the thumb and fingers are all down-strokes. That kind of music works best on an open-backed banjo. While the two styles are transferable, they just sound better on the instruments they were intended for.
Hope that makes sense and helps.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 02-22-2012, 09:39 AM
wcap wcap is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 4,414
Default

I don't know about all 5-string banjo designs, but the resonator on my banjo, as well as all the resonator mounting plates or flanges or whatever they are called, could be removed if I wanted to turn mine into an open back banjo.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
Old 02-22-2012, 10:59 AM
wcap wcap is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 4,414
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by zabdart View Post
From my own experience: First of all, right-hand technique on banjo is entirely different from guitar because of that high drone 5th string. Your brain is going to rebel a little in the beginning.
Yes, though certain other aspects of some banjo playing styles are remarkably similar to certain guitar styles. The sorts of fingerings often used in melodic banjo arrangements are often very similar to some of the fingerings I encounter in some classical guitar pieces.

By the way, if you have ever experienced the charm of a ukulele (in standard tuning with the 4th string a higher pitch than the 3rd) played fingerstyle you have experienced some of what I also find so charming about 5-string banjos. That 5th string on a 5-string banjo is what makes the instrument really really cool.

Last edited by wcap; 02-22-2012 at 11:06 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
Old 02-22-2012, 01:29 PM
the.ronin the.ronin is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Posts: 407
Default

WOW. Thanks for all this info. Saved me a lot of googling! I too have been drawn to the sound of the banjo particularly from listening to so much Mumford & Sons. (And of course the movie Deliverance ... LOL.)

Quote:
Originally Posted by wcap View Post
I went the other direction: I was an obsessive, compulsive 5-string banjo player for close to 30 years before becoming an obsessive compulsive fingerstyle/classical guitar player (which started about 8 years ago).

I'm a banjo snob, and I tend to view 5-string banjos as the real deal, and everything else as being inferior. OK, yes, tenor banjos are legitimate instruments (but really, whole different beasts), as are 6 string banjos (I guess), but a 5-string banjo is something special that presents some unique opportunities that other (inferior ) forms of banjo lack. A 6-string banjo could probably be a a lot of fun, but if you want a really genuine, traditional banjo sound I don't think you are going to get this without a 5-string banjo. If you want to sound like Pete Seeger or Earl Scruggs or Tony Trischka or Bela Fleck, get a 5 string banjo. If you want to play Foggy Mountain Breakdown (like in the Bonnie and Clyde movie) or The Ballad of Jed Clampett (theme song from The Beverly Hillbillies - people love it when I play this), get a 5-string banjo. If you want to sound like the old traditional clawhammer/frailing style players, get a 5-string banjo. Yes, I'm a banjo snob.

A 5-string banjo has very small intervals between the strings (in standard G tuning anyway), and past the 5th fret (which is where the 5th string starts) the 1st and 5th strings are the same note (and past a certain point on the neck most notes can be played in 4 or 5 different places on the neck - I'm talking about the exact same pitch here). This allows for really really smooth runs of notes, which can be played rapidly with a smoothness that is hard to achieve on a guitar - this is the basis of the banjo sound in some styles of playing (e.g. melodic style). In other styles of playing the 5th string is sometimes (or usually) used as a drone string, and this is integral to other sorts of banjo sounds.

When I play guitar I miss the ease of playing smooth chromatic runs and such that can come so naturally on 5-string banjo. When I play banjo, I miss the bass notes and the relative ease with which you can have multiple things going on at once (e.g. in a well developed fingerstyle guitar arrangement).

Any instrument, whether guitar or banjo, is going to take a lot of time before you feel really comfortable and competent. When I first started banjo I played Foggy Mountain Breakdown (Scruggs style) and Cripple Creek (a frailing/clawhammer arrangement) over and over and over and over..........and over and over.......and over and over again, really badly, for about a year. Then I started adding some pieces, which I also played badly. About 2 years and many hours into this things really started to come together, and a lot of things I had been working on and playing badly for some time started to really sound good.

When I started playing fingerstyle guitar in earnest (after decades with banjo), I sounded pretty bad, and felt pretty clumsy for a few years. It was not until I had been at this for about 5 years that I really started to feel I was playing things really well (and I certainly was no beginner when it came to stringed instruments in general).

I don't think banjo is fundamentally any harder than fingerstyle/classical guitar. Due to the nature of the instrument, banjo players tend to play a lot in certain keys (G is "Gods Key" in standard tuning on 5-string banjo, though people also play a lot in C, and D, and there are a variety of alternate tunings that are commonly used, such as C, D, and D minor tuning). Standard tuning on 5-string banjo is an open G chord. Given the fact that a lot of pieces tend to be arranged in a few commonly used keys, and given the narrow neck, and the light strings that many banjo players prefer, the left hand tends to have it easier on 5-string banjo than on guitar. The bigger challenge is in training your right hand (but then when you go back to guitar your guitar playing friends will be amazed by your right hand!).

I see no advantage to playing mandolin first. Play mandolin if you want to play mandolin (I play mandolin too - it is much more like guitar flatpicking than banjo playing). If you are attracted to banjo (a sign of good taste, in my book ), then by all means get a banjo and give it a shot.

I learned with the aid of several main books:

The classic by Pete Seeger:

http://www.amazon.com/5-String-Banjo...bxgy_mov_img_b

Earl Scruggs' classic book:

http://www.amazon.com/Earl-Scruggs-5...9888678&sr=8-2

Tony Trischka's wonderful melodic banjo book (I used an earlier edition of this that I got in about 1980):

http://www.elderly.com/books/items/01-963149.htm

Peter Wernick's Bluegrass Banjo book:

http://www.amazon.com/Bluegrass-Banj.../dp/0825601487


Also, a big collection of banjo arrangements (that might interest you in a few years maybe) can be found here:

http://www.frettedinstrumentsnyc.com

(This is also a mother lode of fantastic fingerstyle guitar arrangements!)


I also had some Flatt and Scruggs records that I listened to a lot (and listened to slowed down to hear better what was going on - the Petticoat Junction theme song sounded pretty funny with the female voices (saying "Petticoat Junction") slowed down and sounding like big burly but rather effeminate men!).

I started out playing a Sears banjo from a Sears outlet store, and played that for about 5 or 6 years before building a much MUCH nicer banjo from a Stewart MacDonald kit. I can't stand to play that old Sears banjo now (but still have it). You don't need a top of the line banjo to learn on, but don't get a piece of junk (like my Sears banjo) either!

Your guitar knowledge will make learning banjo easier, and your guitar skills and sensibilities will enhance your banjo playing. Learning banjo will also enhance and transform what you do on guitar in some very nice ways.
__________________
GUITARS »» ESTEVE 7SR | APARICIO AA52 | SAEZ MARIN 715 | TAYLOR GC3 | MARTIN D-1GT | GIBSON LPMM
UKULELES »» KAMAKA HF-3 | KOALOHA KTM-00-R | KANILEA K-1 C SF | KOALOHA KCM-00 | OHANA SK50-MG
Reply With Quote
  #13  
Old 02-22-2012, 03:26 PM
Bravejoy Bravejoy is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: North Hollywood, CA
Posts: 186
Default

I've been playing both guitar and banjo for about 48 years. Learned 'em together, so my playing style on each instrument is influenced by the other.

There's lot's of different styles of banjo playing. Check out www.banjohangout.org for some lively discussions. I don't play bluegrass. I do a mixture of frailing (usually called claw hammer nowadays), two-finger picking, and three-finger picking (non-Scruggs) plus other stuff that could be classified as "folk banjo"

I do all this on a banjo that would be called a "blue-grass" banjo, but it don't care what I do with my fingers. Only the blue-grass and old-time police care about that, and I don't let 'em bother me none.

Whatever style you decide on, it'll take a lot of retraining of your fingers. That fifth string and the different layout of the fingerboard make all the difference in the world.
__________________
Robert Taylor

Taylor DN3 (6 string Dreadnought)
Taylor 356e (12 string Grand Symphony)
Taylor 326ce (8 string Baritone Grand Symphony)
Gold Star GF-85 (banjo)
McSpadden 4FHCC-S (Mountain Dulcimer)
Kamaka HF-1 (Centennial Edition Ukulele)

Sometimes I sits and thinks, but mostly I just sits.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
Old 02-22-2012, 06:50 PM
wcap wcap is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 4,414
Default

One thing to note though is that in standard G tuning on a 5-string banjo the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th strings are tuned the same as in standard tuning on guitar. That being said, despite that commonality, the banjo doesn't feel as much like a guitar when playing it (in terms of layout of notes and such) as this information about those three strings might make it seem.

It was interesting though on one occasion when I handed my banjo to a non-banjo playing friend who is an accomplished guitar flatpicker. Using just those three strings he was able, immediately, to improvise all sorts of cool things (with sort of a jazzy flair) on my banjo that sounded nothing like my normal banjo playing, but sounded really nice!
Reply With Quote
  #15  
Old 02-22-2012, 06:52 PM
wcap wcap is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 4,414
Default

By the way, for some inspiration regarding some of the wonderful things you can do with a banjo besides really fast bluegrass music, take a look at this recent thread and the many cool links within:

http://www.acousticguitarforum.com/f...d.php?t=237357
Reply With Quote
Reply

  The Acoustic Guitar Forum > General Acoustic Guitar and Amplification Discussion > Other Musical Instruments

Thread Tools





All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:12 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, The Acoustic Guitar Forum
vB Ad Management by =RedTyger=