A Lot of Great Quarterbacks, but . . .

[Dru Edwards]

If only Brady was as great in the NFL as Gretzky was in the NHL we wouldn't need to have this conversation .

[Scott O]

Originally Posted by Dru Edwards

If only Brady was as great in the NFL as Gretzky was in the NHL we wouldn't need to have this conversation .

Bobby Orr.

[Dru Edwards]

Originally Posted by Scott O

Bobby Orr.

Orr was amazing, no doubt. Shame what happened with Alan Eagleson and Orr's trade to Chicago - never should have happened. Boston offered a better deal but Eagleson lied and never reported the offer to Bobby. Eagleson ended up going to jail for fraud 20 years ago.

[LouieAtienza]

Originally Posted by Scott O

This agument is kinda like the 'who is the best golfer of all time' discussions. All these crazy people try to say it's probably either Tiger of Jack Nicholas. Those guys are ok but Carl Cooper once hit a drive of 787 yards. Could Tiger or Jack do that? No! All they could do was play clutch golf and dominate in the short game. Give me gunslinger Carl any day. Tiger and Jack are not that bad though, just not great. Anyone could do what they've done.

Jack has 18 majors. Tiger has 14, and no chance of getting to 18. Jack did it with a persimmon driver and steel shaft, that he could knock 300 yards.

Driving it far doesn't make you the greatest golfer. If that was the barometer then everyone at the WLD competition would be the best golfer. The top WLD would probably rank 188 on top earning caddies on the PGA.