I have recently played both and honestly cannot pick one over the other.
To me, it all comes down to individual guitars. Both the J35 and D18 I played a few weeks ago were exceptional guitars.
I hope to purchase one or the other in a few months, however when I finally decide it will be based on the particular guitar.
Both of these would are stellar choices at their respective price points, IMHO.
__________________
Fender Thin Skin 55 Tele
Gibson J45 Custom Shop KOA
|