Here is what I had from your list:
- DM Promag Gold - My first magnetic and my least favorite
- LR Baggs M1 - My favorite from the list; has a touch of acoustic sound to it
- Fishman Neo-D - Just okay but had some noise
- Fishman Rare Earth - My second favorite; pleasing tone and warmer
I would go with the M1 and the Rare Earth to start. The M1 was brighter than the Rare Earth, but both sounded good to me. For strumming, I prefer the M1 over the Rare Earth. For a lighter touch, I can see using the Rare Earth over the M1.