I will just say that it shouldn't be a surprise that the relatively dry sound of an all mahogany guitar would be a lot easier to record well at home, and would sound better through computer speakers, than a more complex sounding guitar, which I assume your Goodall is. I honestly believe the Martins are a great choice for that application.
I agree, you don't have to spend a fortune to get a nice sounding guitar. But the quality of the files, and the equipment through which people listen to music off Facebook just doesn't support any conclusion in this case. Maybe the songs are just better?
|