Quote:
Originally Posted by TBman
It's become a free for all in S&T due to unrestricted posting privileges. I remember putting up a tune and it would sit in the top 20 for some time. Not anymore.
Back to the critiquing though, if people remember that the criticism has to be restricted to execution, not content, then maybe it stands a chance to be helpful. Again, the subforum wouldn't be for songwriting, just for guitar playing. Songwriting can go in S&T. It wouldn't be a place for reviews of a original piece even it was an instrumental.
|
I think this would attract too niche an audience and would inevitably get lots of threads deleted with those assuming it was fine to ask for critiques of originals. I’m not really sure what the purpose of limiting it to execution is.
I also don’t really see the benefit of limiting S&T to charter members. I have been one in the past, and might do it again, but limiting it to charter members would just result in the same dozen or two regulars posting and no new talent.