Thanks Todd. Is there any disadvantage to using a 1 3/4" one on a 1 11/16" guitar do you know?

I have a Mckinney-elliot for each of my two guitars. I received one as a gift and bought the other. I agree others will do fine, but I enjoy the craftsmanship of their capos and like supporting small businesses in the industry (they are located just up the road from me).

I'm sorely tempted, for similar reasons, though it's not exactly a local business to me!

Supporting good craftmanship would be a plus for me too ( in favor of the Elliott) capos. They even have a Tony Rice model from which they donate a piece of the price to him in this bad times for Tony...

Here are the measurements on a couple of mine. The "W" or "Wide" model is the 1 3/4" version, and the width measurement is just under the top bar. You can measure your neck and see how far up either will go on your neck.

Personally, I see no advantage to the wider one a narrow neck. The standard width will go up to about the 7th fret or so on most 1 11/16" guitars and up to 4 or 5 on most 1 3/4" guitars. I can get away with that most of the time, since seldom capo past 4 anyway.

The only down side to the wide version on a narrow neck is the that you have more "extra" sticking out the sides when capo'd at the first or second fret. Part of the appeal of these capos is sleek fit, so the overly wide capo negates some of that advantage.

If you want a truly one-size-fits-all capo for future use, get the 1 3/4" version. If you want the best fit on your D-28, get the 1 11/16" version.

McKinney-Elliott
2.005" wide
29 grams

McKinney-Elliott "W"
2.102" wide
29 grams

I've just gone through the checkout process to find they want over $60 for shipping to the UK. I think this makes it a deal breaker :(

Thanks again Todd, that's really helpful.

In two minds now with the crazy shipping!

The two single reasons why I also use an Elliott capo.

A. You can bend do bends on the E and B strings without the string slipping.
B. The capo will not pull the strings out of tune.

I used to only use Shubbs for reason A. However, in spite of how good the Shubb was, you had to use extra care when putting it on. Otherwise it would pull the strings slightly out of tune.

Many folks balk at the higher price, and perhaps that may be due to the small size of the component. But when I think about it I realize that for me, the Elliott is the perfect tool for the job. If I were a carpenter I wouldn't think twice about laying out the extra bread for a well designed, sturdy hammer, especially one that has the same type of warranty!!

Anyone want to trade a wide Elliott elite for my standard width one? ;-)

Used a Shubb for years, even though I thought it was crazy money 35 years ago when I first got one. It was well engineered & built and was a huge step up from the old elastic type I'd had previously.

With my recent bluegrass obsession, I'm using a capo more than ever, so bought a couple new ones to try out - a Paige and a Planet Waves NS (aesthetically Kyser-type clamp jobs trigger an involuntary gag reflex...). I liked both the new ones, and really appreciated the ability to store the Paige above the nut at jams. The Paige is a little flexy though; the NS is not.

With the addition of a 28-style guitar w/volute the Paige won't fit above the nut, so I finally sprung for a Mckinney-Elliot and it has all the pros I've enjoyed in other capos, with price as the only con. Also, there's no dampening or loss of tone at all with the Elliot. I still use the Paige on one guitar and generally have the NS as a backup (fits all width necks) when I'm out & about.

The Shubb is a little fussier than the rest up the neck a bit, so doesn't get much use, but I still think it's a cool capo and it served me well. Do still use my banjo Shubb, though.

My experience with the Elliotts, compared to the Paige is similar to Todd's.

The Paige is not in the same league, but then it shouldn't be expected to compete with handmade precision machinery.

I also bought one of the Tony Rice Elliott's as a show of support for Tony.

Here it is with the Hybrid which my Darlin' MaryAnn gave me for xmas a few years ago.

http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/n...ce%20Stuff.jpg

My experience of the Elliott's and I also prefer the Elliott-McKinney model for ease of use, is that they simply, to my ears, sound the most like the nut than any other capo I have used. The harmonics ring as loud and I do not experience any loss of tone or volume. Agree with what Todd and Toby have expressed. But, as anything with guitars go, hands and ears are not created equal and you may experience it differently. If you could borrow one to try out, that would be ideal.

A friend of mine thought I was crazy spending that much on a capo and then she came over and tried it and could immediately hear the difference. Another friend of mine bought one and didn't think they sounded any different at all. So as we are fond of typing here on the forum - YMMV!

Best,
Jayne

Thanks all, I've emailed them to see if they have a cheaper shipping option.

I have two of them. One for each guitar. They live full-time behind the nut. I have the Elite and the Hybrid. I slightly prefer the later, but both are stellar. I recommend getting one size larger, so it fits further behind the nut when not in use. Also, I had my tech shrink wrap the arms so that it doesn't chew up the wood over time. See pic below.

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...ps3ca3328e.jpg