Takamine or Seagull?
I'm a beginner about to buy my first acoustic/electric. I've narrowed my decison down to two guitars:
Takamine G Series 340C @ $379 or Seagull S6 Original Q1 @ $529 I know this may not be an "apples to apples" comparison because the Seagull is $150 more but that's where I find myself after looking, playing and listening to different guitars. I can afford to buy the Seagull if it is really worth the extra money but I'm trying to decide if it makes sense to do this. Because I'm a beginner, I don't have the experience & expertise to compare and contrast these from a player's perspective. I'd appreciate any comments/guidance you can provide. Thanks. |
If you plan on plugging in.....Takamine hands down.
|
Quote:
Regards, Glenn |
Do you have any friend or acquaintance who plays who can go shopping with you, and might be able to point out any potential issues from a "player's perspective" (as you say)?
If you haven't done so already I'd also make sure to have someone else - if not a friend, at least the salesperson - play both for you so you can just listen and concentrate on how they sound. Good luck! |
For a beginner, I would recommend a guitar without electronics. for the same price you will get a better guitar. Also think about used guitars. A used Seagull S6 w/o electronics is about half the price of the one you mentioned. You can find a really good deal in the used market. I have not tried the Tak, so can't help you there, but the S6 is a truly a great guitar. And you'll probably get a lot of other suggestions such as a Yamaha FG730s. Also an awesome guitar and there is one for sale in the classified (not mine). Good Luck.:)
|
Take the Tak
|
Not to point out the obvious but......do make sure and play them both before deciding. If you can find a store that has more than one of each model play them all. Even the same models can sound very different. I played a $900.00 Taylor recently that sounded better than every 3k acoustic in the store. I was shocked.
|
Have you played them? Never underestimate "comfort." Most Seagulls come with a wider than average neck. Many people love that size. I do not. Most Taks come with a slightly narrower neck than most guitars. Some people like that size, some do not. (I do).
I wouldn;t play a guitar that doesn't feel right. |
i very much agree with Glenwillow that acoustically the s6 sounds much better (and is louder, btw) than the tak, but the tak sounds better when plugged in.
|
and...
I would echo Glenn as well. I have had both and while I loved the Tak, it sounded muffled...I guess you could call it that, while unplugged. Plugged in it was a dandy.
The Seagull sounds great either way... And...made in North America. Godin guitars (Seagull's parent company) are a tremendous value for the money. Good luck and welcome to the forum (if no one has said that to you).:) |
I prefer seagull over tak. but there is a big price difference which could make me go the other way if I was in the situation.
|
I would like to echo what others have said, go and try them both. Plugged in hmmm in my opinion an electro acoustic is only as good as the pick-up.
If you want to play the Seagull louder through an Amp then put a mic in front of it. Regards, Marty |
The S6 is has a sound all its own, and very nice. I kept one for several years and was never disappointed. It S6 might be a better all around guitar, it handles open tunings and the neck, while wide, has a fairly low profile and should not be difficult to play. Does the TAK have a solid top? Here's what I found:
# Spruce top # Mahogany back and sides If an add does not say solid, it is almost always laminate. This is not to say it's a bad guitar, but the S6 does have a solid top. I have played a parlor G model TAK and it was light and responsive. Good luck |
While I liked the sound of the Seagull S6 and find nothing wrong with it whatsoever, the Takamine (G406S) that I played pleasantly surprised me. If I was looking for a smaller guitar, I'd pick this one over anything that Taylor or Martin is making at the moment.
Unfortunately, I haven't had a chance to play the G340C yet. Takamine makes decent sounding guitars though. Though you might have the "experience and expertise", I'd suggest that you (or a friend) try out the guitars at the store, and let YOUR ears decide. |
My experience with the two brands leads me to the conclusion that Takamines work well plugged in, but do not have the tone of Seagulls when unplugged. I don't know which pickup comes installed with the S6 you're looking at, but there are many good pickups (K&K PWM comes to mind) which could be installed after your purchase, and which would retain the excellent tone Seagulls are known for.
-Raf |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:03 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, The Acoustic Guitar Forum